Corrosion blamed on salt-water pools
WFAA.com:
Dallas Fort Worth
08:48 AM CDT on
Saturday, May 12, 2007
By DAVID SCHECHTER / WFAA-TV
The backyard pool is one of the true joys
of a North Texas summer. And as many as 65 percent of new pools
are built with salt-water filtration systems. But a
growing number of families say the salt is corroding parts of
their prized pools. Steve Riley's company cleans and
maintains pools in Dallas. He says he's finding rusted and
deteriorated stainless steel components in the growing number of
pools in North Texas with salt-water filtration systems.
Proponents say salt pools are better than traditional chlorine.
They say it leaves the skin feeling soft and reduces eye
irritation. But Riley says many pool cleaners believe
there's a problem with salt and he's certain it's causing
problems for his clients.
Like Sharon Collazo. She says the salt
water is eating away at the decorative limestone surrounding her
pool. Repairs could cost thousands. "It's like eating little
pieces of it away," said Collazo. The decorative stone on Amy
Johnson's pool is also pocking and discoloring. She's removed
her saltwater filter but also had to replace a $1,000 heater.
"We had no idea this was a potential
disadvantage of owning it," said Johnson.
Phil McEwen's built hundreds of pools in
North Texas. And while some builders almost exclusively install
the popular salt systems, McEwen is one of a growing number of
pool builders who will no longer will, unless a customer signs a
release.
"We anticipate there will be issues later
on caused by the salt system. That as a builder we can't be held
responsible for if we explain to them the issues we have with
salt," McEwen said.
But Houston pool builder Robert Tomlinson
says poor maintenance by owners is to blame. He heads the Texas
chapter of the Association of Pool and Spa Professionals and
says 98 percent of his pools are salt. He says companies that
make the salt systems are conducting joint tests to figure out
what's causing the problems.
"I don't believe the corrosion we've heard
about in the past is a valid issue. And I do greatly await the
results of the test being done," Tomlinson said.
And one company, Goldline, wrote WFAA that
stone naturally deteriorates. That it's affected by a range of
factors like climate, weather, traffic, maintenance. It says the
use of salt water in a pool can be one of those factors.
But, both Amy Johnson and Sharon Collazo
say they were never told about any potential problems with salt.
You always should know everything you can know when you're
investing this kind of money in your home," said Collazo.
Pool cleaner Steve Riley expects to see
more and more deteriorated parts and decorative stone. And says
makers of salt water systems need to be upfront about potential
problems that can be expensive to fix.